Navigating the world of menstrual products can sometimes feel like deciphering a complex puzzle. With an ever-growing emphasis on sustainability and comfort, many are turning away from traditional sanitary pads and tampons in search of better alternatives. Enter the menstrual cup and menstrual disc – two revolutionary products that have changed the game for people menstruating worldwide. But which one is right for you? What are menstrual cups and period disks? In this comprehensive breakdown, we’ll explore the ins and outs of both options, helping you make an informed decision based on your lifestyle, comfort, and menstrual flow.
What Is a Menstrual Cup?
A menstrual cup is a flexible cup designed for use inside the vagina during your period to collect menstrual blood. The material most commonly used in making these cups is medical-grade silicone, which is safe, hypoallergenic, and suitable for long-term contact with your body. You might also find cups made of rubber or latex, but silicone is by far the most popular due to its durability and comfort.
The benefits of using menstrual cups are vast. They’re eco-friendly, reduce the amount of menstrual product waste, and cost-efficient, as a single cup can last up to ten years with proper care. Now let’s know what is the use of a menstrual cup. Menstrual cups can hold more blood than traditional tampons, offering longer protection, which is especially beneficial for those with a heavy flow. The most interesting thing is there are also menstrual cups for teenagers available!
Choosing the right menstrual cup size is crucial for comfort and effectiveness. Most brands offer at least two sizes – one recommended for people under 30 who haven’t given birth vaginally, and another for those over 30 or who have given birth vaginally. The right size ensures a snug fit, preventing leaks and discomfort.
What Is a Menstrual Disc?
A menstrual disc operates on a similar principle to the cup but with a few key differences. It’s a flexible, disk-shaped device that tucks into the vaginal fornix, capturing menstrual blood. Like cups, discs are often made from medical-grade silicone, ensuring they’re safe and comfortable to use.
The benefits of using a menstrual disc include less frequent changes compared to tampons and pads, less risk of leakage due to its unique placement, and the possibility of mess-free sexual intercourse while the disc is inserted. Additionally, many find discs to be a more comfortable option, as they can’t be felt when positioned correctly.
Choosing the right menstrual disc size can be somewhat simpler than with cups, as many brands offer a “one size fits most” option. However, some brands do offer size variations based on factors like vaginal canal length, cervix height, and menstrual flow volume.
Comparison Between Menstrual Disc VS Menstrual Cup
Menstrual Cup | Menstrual Disc | |
Placement | Inside the vaginal canal | Over cervix |
Body-safe materials | Yes | Yes |
Infection/TSS risks | Low | Low |
Suction | Yes | No |
Higher capacity than pads/tampons | Yes | Yes |
Night use | Yes | Yes |
Handling Heavy Flow | Yes | Yes |
Period sex | No | Yes |
Heavy flows | Yes | Yes |
IUD-friendly | Yes | Yes |
Beginner-friendly | Yes | Yes |
Exercise-friendly | Yes | Yes |
Auto-empty | No | Yes |
Longer usage time than tampons | Yes | Yes |
Mess-free removal | Yes | No |
Comfortable | Yes | Yes |
Reusable | Yes | No(most brands) |
Eco-friendly | Yes | No(unless reusable) |
Better value for money | Yes | No(unless reusable) |
How to Use Menstrual Cup vs Disc
Understanding the proper use of menstrual cups and discs is fundamental before diving into the specifics of each. Both require insertion into the vagina, but their placements and removal techniques differ slightly, impacting the user’s experience.
How to Insert & Remove a Menstrual Cup
A menstrual cup is bell-shaped and is designed to sit low in the vaginal canal, just below the cervix. To insert, one typically folds the cup using one of several fold methods (such as the C-fold or punch-down fold), then gently inserts it into the vagina, allowing it to open and form a seal against the vaginal walls. Removal involves gently pinching the base to break the seal and then pulling the stem to slide the cup out.
Inserting a menstrual cup involves a similar process but with its specifics:
- Wash your hands thoroughly to maintain menstrual cup hygiene.
- Fold the cup using a fold that works best for you (C-fold or punch-down fold are popular options).
- While relaxed, insert the cup into the vagina, aiming it towards the base of the spine. The cup should pop open and form a seal to prevent leaks.
- To remove, wash your hands, pinch the base of the cup to break the seal, and gently pull it out.
Sirona Recommends:
Menstrual Cup with Pouch Duo Pack – Small/Medium:
This duo pack includes both small and medium-sized menstrual cups, catering to varying flow levels and providing up to 12 hours of protection. The cups come with a convenient pouch for storage and are made from high-quality, medical-grade silicone.
Menstrual Cup Sterilizer and Cleanser
Ensuring your menstrual cup is clean and sterilised is essential for your health. This Menstrual Cup Sterilizer and Cleanser from Sirona is specially formulated to clean your cup effectively, keeping it hygienic and ready for use.
How to Insert & Remove a Menstrual Disc
Conversely, a menstrual disc has a more shallow, round shape and is inserted by squeezing it into a figure-eight shape. It is then pushed back and upward until it sits at the base of the cervix, tucking behind the pubic bone. To remove, one hooks their finger under the rim or the designated loop, gently pulling it forward and out.
Inserting a menstrual disc can initially seem daunting, but with practice, it becomes a straightforward process. Here’s a simplified guide:
- Wash your hands thoroughly to maintain hygiene.
- Fold the disc. Most discs are inserted by squeezing them into a figure-eight or taco shape.
- Gently insert the folded disc into the vagina, aiming towards the tailbone. Ensure it sits below the cervix.
- Tuck the edge of the disc behind the pubic bone to secure it in place. When properly inserted, you shouldn’t be able to feel the disc.
Removing the disc also requires care:
- Wash your hands well.
- Insert a finger into the vagina and hook it under the rim or edge of the disc.
- Gently pull the disc out, keeping it level to avoid spills.
Sirona Recommends:
Reusable Menstrual Disc – Large
This large-sized, reusable Sirona menstrual disc offers up to 12 hours of protection and is designed for a comfortable fit. It’s made from 100% medical-grade silicone, ensuring safety and durability. Ideal for those seeking an eco-friendly alternative to pads and tampons.
Choosing between a menstrual cup and a disc largely depends on personal preference, comfort, and lifestyle needs. Some may prefer the cup for its eco-friendliness and cost-effectiveness, while others might find the disc’s comfort and the possibility of mess-free intercourse more appealing. Ultimately, both products offer a sustainable and comfortable alternative to traditional menstrual products, making them worth considering for anyone looking to make the switch.
How to Choose between Menstrual Cups or Discs?
Choosing between a menstrual cup and a disc can seem like a daunting task, but it doesn’t have to be. Consider the following factors:
- Comfort and Fit: Cups require a snug fit to prevent leaks, while discs offer a bit more flexibility in positioning. Consider what might feel more comfortable for your body.
- Ease of Use: Both products have a learning curve, but personal anatomy and flexibility can make one easier to use than the other.
- Lifestyle Needs: If you’re active, travel frequently, or have a heavier flow, one product may suit your lifestyle better. Menstrual cups often need less frequent emptying, making them ideal for those on the go.
- Sexual Activity: Only menstrual discs allow for mess-free intercourse while in use, which may be a significant deciding factor for some.
So now you know what is a menstrual cup and a menstrual disc. Deciding between a menstrual cup and a disc is a personal choice that depends on a variety of factors, including comfort, lifestyle, and menstrual flow. Both options offer a sustainable, cost-effective, and comfortable alternative to traditional menstrual products. With a bit of trial and error, you can find the perfect product that fits your needs and preferences.
FAQs About Menstrual Disc vs Cup
You can have mess-free intercourse with a menstrual disc, but not with a menstrual cup.
Yes, but it’s recommended to consult with a healthcare provider first.
Both can be worn for up to 12 hours, depending on your flow, but should be cleaned regularly.
Some users report reduced period cramps, possibly due to the lack of chemicals found in traditional products.
Yes, both products can be used, but finding the right fit may take some experimentation.
Yes, but it’s advised to consult with your healthcare provider first.
It depends on personal preferences and lifestyle needs.
Yes, both discs and cups can be worn overnight.
This varies by individual; both have a learning curve.
Yes, both are designed for long-term use with proper care.
Related Stories:
Menstrual Cup vs Tampons: Discover the pros and cons of menstrual cups and tampons to determine which is the superior choice for your menstrual health and lifestyle. Read on!
Can Using Menstrual Cups Cause UTI?: Wondering if menstrual cups can cause UTI? Read on for all the deets!
Why is inserting a menstrual cup painful?: From reasons why inserting a menstrual cup might be painful for you to tips to avoid it, we have got all the deets for you. Read on!
Prevent Menstrual Cup From Leaking: If you’re experiencing menstrual cup leakage, we’ve got you covered with a handy guide for you. Check it out!
Period rash: Period rashes are annoying and discomforting. Read on to learn the possible causes, ways to prevent them and a few period hygiene tips.